The Great Replacement Versus Systemic Racism

I had an argument with a leftist on Quora recently. He claimed that The Great Replacement is a “far-right myth.” I countered with some sources and an article from Amren, explaining what we mean by The Great Replacement; I had told him that he probably has no idea what we mean by the term, and that he therefore cannot claim that it’s a myth. This is how he defined it:

Peter von Elbing 

It means that the so called “elites” have allegedly a “plan” to replace white people in European countries and America by brown-skinned foreigners from Africa, Arab countries, Asia and South/Middle America. That is extreme right-wing racist bullshit spread for at least the last ten years, coming initially from Russian propaganda channels.

The extreme right-wing in Israel is also bought in by this BS.

This was my response:

No. That’s a cartoonish/Protocols of the Elder of Zion type understanding of the Great Replacement. Fact: For the most part, the ruling elites hate White people as a group. They make no secret of it, and they’ve been very outspoken about it. Fact: Elites CELEBRATE the demographic changes that are making Whites a minority all over the world. Fact: White ARE decreasing in number and political clout all over the West – after decades of being encouraged to have fewer kids.

Now they’re being forced to subsidize the large families of non-White immigrants. A person needs to be a special kind of naive to believe that the elites, who openly hate Whites, have nothing to do with immigration policies that make Whites a minority. We don’t claim that there is a single “plan” at work here, and that a bunch of “Elders of Zion” (so to speak) sit around a table discussing how to exterminate Whites. There are many localized plans that seem to work toward that end ultimately. Here. This may help.

We can turn the tables on Great Replacement deniers:

Leftist: The Great Replacement theory says that there’s an elite cabal that has a plan to replace White people with non-Whites.

Let’s apply this thinking to “Systemic Racism” (toward non-Whites).

“Systemic Racism” is a far-left conspiracy theory that there’s an elite cabal that coordinates a plan to discriminate against non-Whites, especially blacks.

Not many leftists would accept this definition; they’d characterize it as “cartoonish” and unrealistic. Instead, they’d explain to us that Systemic Racism (AKA “Structural Racism”) is much more complicated than that. It’s a societal result of a) historic injustices, b) legacy prejudices and c) subconscious behaviors and attitudes that reinforce anti-POC discrimination. The end result is “Systemic Racism!”

It’s similar with The Great Replacement – with one major difference: All of the “evidence” cited in favor of anti-POC “Systemic Racism” can be attributed to Innate racial differences, cultural differences and backlash against preferential treatment. There IS NO Systemic Racism against non-Whites in the Western world today. but there absolutely IS a Great Replacement occurring. Evidence of The Great Replacement is before our very eyes, and quantifiable with many statistics.

There are no powerful or influential people in the Western world who espouse hatred toward non-Whites. There are no laws or policies targeting non-Whites – but there are plenty of powerful people publicly rejoicing at the demographic decline of White people, and there are plenty of laws and policies targeting Whites.

There may not be a council of elites, similar to the “Elders of Zion” conspiring to replace White people wherever they are. There certainly are entrenched attitudes and policies that inexorably lead to White replacement. This ideological infrastructure is reinforced by various forms of official propaganda, legacy media (also propaganda), the education system, churches, many large corporations and a variety of NGOs.

One might argue that the ideology that led to The Great Replacement had its origin in the Frankfurt School, a group of (mainly) Jewish Marxists that fled Germany with the rise of Hitler. It’s also possible that groups such as the WMF, and even influential people in the EU, are working toward The Great Replacement. However, we should acknowledge The Great Replacement even if there is no cohesive group of elites behind it. At this point, it doesn’t need any actual leadership, since it runs on momentum. Anybody who steps out of line is instantly branded a “racist” and his influence is diminished. He might even be arrested or fined, especially in Canada and Europe.

“Systemic Racism” against non-Whites is a myth. The Great Replacement is a fact.